| 
			
				| 
								
															
										
											| 
								
									
										| 
											
												|  |  
												|  |  
												| 
													
														
															| 
																
																	
																		|  |  |  
																		|  | 
																		  |  
																		|  | Primary 
																		vote 
																		could 
																		mean no 
																		Black 
																		Detroit 
																		member 
																		in 
																		Congress 
 By COREY 
																		WILLIAMS
 apnews.com
 
 DETROIT 
																		- State 
																		Rep. 
																		Shri 
																		Thanedar 
																		won 
																		Michigan’s 
																		13th 
																		Congressional 
																		Democratic 
																		primary, 
																		topping 
																		a field 
																		of nine 
																		candidates 
																		in a 
																		district 
																		that 
																		covers 
																		most of 
																		Detroit 
																		and 
																		potentially 
																		leaving 
																		the 
																		predominantly 
																		Black 
																		city 
																		next 
																		term 
																		without 
																		Black 
																		representation 
																		in 
																		Congress 
																		for the 
																		first 
																		time 
																		since 
																		the 
																		early 
																		1950s.
 
 Results 
																		from 
																		Tuesday’s 
																		election 
																		show 
																		Thanedar, 
																		an 
																		immigrant 
																		from 
																		India, 
																		defeating 
																		state 
																		Rep. 
																		Adam 
																		Hollier 
																		and 
																		attorney 
																		Portia 
																		Roberson. 
																		Martell 
																		Bivings, 
																		who is 
																		Black, 
																		ran 
																		unopposed 
																		in 
																		Tuesday’s 
																		Republican 
																		primary 
																		for the 
																		13th 
																		District, 
																		but is a 
																		longshot 
																		to win 
																		the 
																		general 
																		election 
																		in the 
																		heavily 
																		Democratic 
																		district.
 
 Detroit 
																		has not 
																		been 
																		without 
																		a Black 
																		representative 
																		in 
																		Congress 
																		since 
																		before 
																		Charles 
																		Diggs 
																		Jr. took 
																		office 
																		in 1955. 
																		Diggs 
																		was 
																		joined 
																		in 
																		Congress 
																		in 1965 
																		by 
																		Democrat 
																		John 
																		Conyers, 
																		who 
																		retained 
																		his 
																		congressional 
																		seat for 
																		more 
																		than 50 
																		years.
 
 Detroit 
																		is about 
																		80% 
																		Black 
																		and all 
																		of the 
																		other 
																		candidates 
																		in the 
																		primary 
																		were 
																		Black.
 
 “This 
																		race was 
																		not 
																		about 
																		me,” 
																		Thanedar 
																		said in 
																		a 
																		statement 
																		Wednesday. 
																		“Michigan’s 
																		13th 
																		Congressional 
																		district 
																		is one 
																		of the 
																		poorest 
																		in the 
																		country, 
																		and I 
																		will 
																		fight 
																		for 
																		economic 
																		and 
																		racial 
																		justice 
																		in 
																		Congress.”
 
 The 13th 
																		District 
																		— 
																		redrawn 
																		through 
																		redistricting 
																		after 
																		Michigan 
																		lost a 
																		seat 
																		following 
																		the 
																		census — 
																		is 
																		currently 
																		represented 
																		by 
																		Democrat 
																		Rashida 
																		Tlaib, 
																		who ran 
																		in the 
																		redrawn 
																		12th 
																		Congressional 
																		District 
																		and won 
																		Tuesday.
 
 The 
																		Independent 
																		Citizens 
																		Redistricting 
																		Commission 
																		in 
																		January 
																		finalized 
																		the U.S. 
																		House 
																		and 
																		legislative 
																		maps 
																		that 
																		will 
																		last 10 
																		years. 
																		The 
																		plans 
																		are 
																		fairer 
																		politically 
																		to 
																		Democrats 
																		but have 
																		drawn 
																		criticism 
																		from 
																		Black 
																		legislators 
																		and the 
																		state’s 
																		civil 
																		rights 
																		department 
																		because 
																		they 
																		slash 
																		the 
																		number 
																		of seats 
																		where 
																		African 
																		Americans 
																		account 
																		for a 
																		majority 
																		of the 
																		voting-age 
																		population.
 
 A 
																		federal 
																		lawsuit 
																		subsequently 
																		filed on 
																		behalf 
																		of a 
																		group of 
																		current 
																		and 
																		former 
																		Black 
																		state 
																		lawmakers 
																		in 
																		Detroit 
																		seeks to 
																		block 
																		the 
																		newly 
																		drawn 
																		districts, 
																		contending 
																		they 
																		illegally 
																		dilute 
																		the 
																		voting 
																		strength 
																		of 
																		African 
																		Americans. 
																		Thanedar’s 
																		victory 
																		confirms 
																		that 
																		claim, 
																		according 
																		to Nabih 
																		Ayad, an 
																		attorney 
																		for the 
																		group.
 
 The suit 
																		alleges 
																		violations 
																		of the 
																		U.S. 
																		Voting 
																		Rights 
																		Act and 
																		the 
																		Michigan 
																		Constitution. 
																		The No. 
																		1 
																		map-drawing 
																		criteria 
																		for the 
																		panel 
																		was to 
																		comply 
																		with the 
																		1965 
																		law, 
																		which 
																		bans 
																		discriminatory 
																		voting 
																		practices 
																		and 
																		procedures.
 
 “We’ve 
																		been 
																		alleging 
																		this all 
																		along, 
																		that it 
																		will 
																		take a 
																		miracle 
																		for some 
																		of these 
																		individuals 
																		to win,” 
																		Ayad 
																		said 
																		Wednesday. 
																		“This is 
																		no 
																		surprise. 
																		Why 
																		should 
																		they be 
																		the 
																		sacrificial 
																		lambs. 
																		It’s a 
																		very, 
																		very sad 
																		day for 
																		the 
																		African 
																		American 
																		power 
																		base 
																		that 
																		worked 
																		for 
																		decades 
																		to get 
																		where 
																		they 
																		are.”
 
 Former 
																		state 
																		Rep. 
																		Sherry 
																		Gay-Dagnogo 
																		has been 
																		vocal 
																		against 
																		the 
																		redrawn 
																		districts 
																		and was 
																		one of 
																		the 
																		candidates 
																		who 
																		failed 
																		to 
																		advance 
																		in the 
																		Democratic 
																		13th 
																		Congressional 
																		District 
																		primary 
																		Tuesday.
 
 “At a 
																		time 
																		when the 
																		Black 
																		community 
																		is 
																		reeling 
																		from a 
																		rollback 
																		of 
																		voting 
																		rights 
																		and 
																		Black 
																		women — 
																		who 
																		already 
																		face 
																		inequity 
																		with 
																		maternal 
																		health 
																		and 
																		barriers 
																		to safe 
																		abortion 
																		care — 
																		deal 
																		with the 
																		impact 
																		of the 
																		Roe v. 
																		Wade 
																		reversal, 
																		Black 
																		representation 
																		in 
																		Congress 
																		for 
																		Michigan 
																		and for 
																		Detroit 
																		matters 
																		now more 
																		than 
																		ever,” 
																		Roberson 
																		said 
																		Wednesday. 
																		“Many 
																		people 
																		woke up 
																		this 
																		morning 
																		justifiably 
																		concerned.”
 
 University 
																		of 
																		Michigan 
																		political 
																		science 
																		professor 
																		Ken 
																		Kollman 
																		said the 
																		crowded 
																		field of 
																		candidates, 
																		and a 
																		lack of 
																		coordination 
																		in the 
																		district 
																		and 
																		among 
																		groups 
																		of 
																		voters, 
																		may have 
																		been 
																		major 
																		factors 
																		in 
																		Thanedar’s 
																		win.
 
 “I would 
																		assume 
																		to many 
																		voters 
																		in 
																		Detroit 
																		it’s a 
																		big deal 
																		and I’m 
																		sure it 
																		is 
																		something 
																		that’s a 
																		big 
																		disappointment 
																		for many 
																		voters 
																		in 
																		Detroit,” 
																		Kollman 
																		said of 
																		the 
																		possibility 
																		of the 
																		city 
																		having 
																		no Black 
																		voices 
																		in 
																		Congress. 
																		“Whether 
																		it will 
																		lead to 
																		different 
																		representation 
																		on 
																		substance 
																		or 
																		issues 
																		depends 
																		a lot on 
																		how the 
																		particular 
																		people 
																		who 
																		represent 
																		Detroit 
																		act in 
																		Congress.”
 
 “Detroit 
																		members 
																		of 
																		Congress 
																		have 
																		been 
																		very 
																		important 
																		and 
																		active 
																		in 
																		things 
																		like the 
																		Congressional 
																		Black 
																		Caucus, 
																		and very 
																		visible 
																		Black 
																		leaders 
																		in the 
																		country,” 
																		he 
																		added.
 
 Roberson 
																		said 
																		there 
																		would be 
																		talk 
																		about 
																		Black 
																		candidates 
																		dividing 
																		the vote 
																		in the 
																		primary, 
																		and that 
																		the 
																		political 
																		establishment 
																		had 
																		tried to 
																		“manufacture 
																		a 
																		consensus 
																		African 
																		American 
																		candidate.”
 
 “The 
																		first 
																		step in 
																		having a 
																		consensus 
																		candidate 
																		is 
																		picking 
																		the most 
																		qualified 
																		candidate,” 
																		she 
																		said. 
																		“That 
																		did not 
																		happen 
																		in this 
																		race.”
 
 Thanedar, 
																		an 
																		entrepreneur, 
																		moved to 
																		Detroit 
																		from Ann 
																		Arbor 
																		and was 
																		elected 
																		in 2020 
																		to 
																		Michigan’s 
																		3rd 
																		House 
																		District. 
																		He spent 
																		more 
																		than $10 
																		million 
																		of his 
																		own 
																		money to 
																		run for 
																		governor 
																		in 2018 
																		but 
																		finished 
																		third 
																		that 
																		year in 
																		the 
																		Democratic 
																		primary. 
																		Thanedar’s 
																		campaign 
																		website 
																		says he 
																		contributed 
																		$5,040,404 
																		to his 
																		campaign 
																		for 
																		Tuesday’s 
																		race.
 
 ___
 
 The 
																		story 
																		has been 
																		corrected 
																		to say 
																		Rashida 
																		Tlaib 
																		represents 
																		the 13th 
																		Congressional 
																		District, 
																		not 
																		Brenda 
																		Lawrence.
 
 
 
																																																								Advertise With Us: 
 Certified Minority Business Enterprise 
																		
																		 
																		    |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |